Showing posts with label Fair Trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fair Trade. Show all posts

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Fair Trade Celebrates Human Rights Day on December 10th, 2011!!!


As a global movement we all agree Fair Trade aims to Empower disadvantaged producers and their communities. Our shared principles reflect business practices which are free from exploitation and based on respect for universal human rights, women's rights, child rights, minority and migrant rights, rights of the disabled, and labour rights. When we examine Fair Trade closely it becomes evident the underpinnings of our global movement are the United Nations Conventions on Human Rights and the internationally recognized conventions of the International Labour Organization (Read A Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade: Human Rights Framework). Succinctly stated, without these international conventions, there would be no solid foundation for Fair Trade.

Over the past several posts I have been emphasizing the importance of integrating a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade as a means of empowerment. When an organization utilizes a Rights-Based Approach they recognize poverty as injustice and includes marginalization, discrimination, and exploitation as central causes of poverty. To integrate a Rights-Based Approach is to strengthen our trade partners not only in trade relations, but in their quality of life; to enjoy the freedoms internationally recognized as inherent to all human beings.  

Longwe's Women's Empowerment Framework
Read: Women's Empowerment and Fair Trade

The crucial step towards empowerment is raising awareness of these rights, to include women's rights. Unfortunately, the fact remains that for many of our producers their rights are not well known; the Universal Declaration of Human Rights remains an abstract idea, an international convention far from their immediate reality. Admittedly, the same is true for many Fair Trade supporters, retailers, importers, buyers and consumers. It is time for change. 

On Saturday, December 10, 2011 the world celebrates Human Rights Day. Considering the strong ties to our global movement, Fair Trade should be leading the way in recognizing the importance of this day! Regardless if you are a Fair Trade producer group, an importer, a coffee roaster, or a retailer, let's celebrate this day of international recognition of our human rights! 

Here are a few suggestions to celebrate Human Rights day locally. These suggestions are for all Fair Traders regardless of where you reside! 

Decorate! Click here to download UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights visual designs for Human Rights day in Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish! 

Display! Click here for videos on human rights from the UN!!! 

Provide a copy of Universal Declaration of Human Rights! Click here for over 300 translations of this pivotal document!!!!! 

Share stories of Human Rights! Click here for a list of stories to share from the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights!

http://www.amnesty.org/

Join with Amnesty International in your country!!! Click here to unite with Amnesty International's efforts in your country. And click here to view Amnesty International's information related to Human Rights issues in every country or by topic! As Fair Trade organizations, retailers, supporters, activists and consumers we need to unite with their voice to ensure everyone's human rights are respected and upheld regardless of where they reside!!


Fair Trade Retailers, everyone in the Fair Trade supply chain truly understands and deeply appreciates that you are busy with the Christmas rush and the last thing you want is to have one more thing to add to the already busy day for retail, ...but the least we can do is make an effort to recognize the global importance of Human Rights Day. Here are some ideas to make this as interesting yet as painless as possible while dealing with the masses of ethically minded consumers making Fair Trade purchases for the holidays. Keep in mind this is a one day event, so make it simple yet prominent - let the conscientious consumers see that Fair Trade is more than simply purchasing products, but about putting people before profits. 

For Fair Trader producers, supporters and activists not preoccupied with the Christmas holiday, set up a special family event for Saturday, December 10th. Keep in mind, children are the future of Fair Trade so let them know how valued they are in our movement. Put up a large poster of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. UNICEF has this document translated into 58 languages at their child-friendly page: http://www.unicef.org/magic/briefing/uncorc.html. For your convenience, here is a downloadable pdf file of UNICEF's child-friendly English version:
Convention on the Rights of the Child Easy Language Poster

Children of all ages like to take on fun challenges - provide them with poster paper, crayons, color pencils and markers and ask them to draw a poster for their favorite Article in the CRC! The purpose is to have children do more than read their rights, that is boring. Make the CRC come alive and reflect on how it is relevant in their lives! Then vote for the best poster from your young artists... 

Send photos of your winning posters on Child Rights to be published on the Journey for Fair Trade!!!! 

When you have some really great entries select the best, take a photo of the winners and send it to me: journer (at) gmail.com and I will feature your young Fair Trade artists on my blog! Make sure you send me information about the featured artists as well!! Try to limit the number to one to three winners in your event. Entries from anywhere in the world are welcome.  



Retailers, show solidarity with your trade partners! You can do the same here by having a corner dedicated to children so the adults can do some shopping. The adults will appreciate the temporary relief and the kids would love a corner committed to them. I am certain you can find high school and college students interested in volunteering to help with a child-centered activity! Add steaming cups of Fair Trade hot chocolate, face painting as well as other creative activities and have fun! The more you provide for the kids, the longer the adults can shop - Retailers, you can't lose here!!!  And don't forget to provide each child with their own color copy of the CRC to post up in their home... Make Child Rights a reality to our Fair Trade consumers! 

For young adults, host a ten minute game show - make it a competition between groups of men and  women and see which team can list the most articles in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights! My bet is the women are able to list more!!! Fortunately the United Nations has translated the UDHR into 131 languages so this activity can be done anywhere: http://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Pages/SearchByLang.aspx. To help, my lovely partner Chou has used her creative talents to provide an English copy of the UDHR here:
Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Follow this competition with an introduction to the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). Begin with inquiring why they think this convention is necessary when the UDHR already exists - it is a great opportunity to dispel a lot of misunderstandings. For help in discussing this convention read A Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade: Understanding CEDAW.  

"Human rights are rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, sex, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, language, or any other status. We are all equally entitled to our human rights without discrimination. These rights are all interrelated, interdependent and indivisible" 
             - UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights

This Human Rights Day, let's make a stand as a global movement! Recognize the importance of this day by raising awareness of our shared human rights locally. Fair Trade is founded upon these rights, and it is time Fair Trade unites with the global recognition of Human Rights Day.

Join Chou, Little Journey, and I in making the future a better place for all of us; join in the global celebration of Human Rights Day on Saturday, December 10th!

Mitch Teberg, MA 
International Consultant
Sustainable Development / Fair Trade
Researcher / Trainer / Consultant 

Feel free to add your comments, suggestions, and ideas below; or commit to holding a special event on December 10th. 



For those who prefer reading black on white, here is the downloadable version of this post on pdf:
Fair Trade Celebrates Human Rights Day on December 10th, 2011

Monday, November 14, 2011

What is Fair Trade? An Interview with Helvetas Vietnam


While working with Helvetas Vietnam, I was interviewed to explain what is Fair Trade. It is important to remember what it is we are working for! Fair Trade is both a global movement for Trade Justice and an ethical business model. 

This interview explores the initial purpose and transformation of the Journey for Fair Trade; how the journey went from research on the perspectives of Fair Trade producers to a Social Action Research project!




In this interview we explore an example of the empowerment of a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade as utilized by Reaching Out, Hoi An, Vietnam! We also explore a comparison of Fair Trade in Vietnam with Fair Trade in the United States.



Mitch Teberg, MA
Sustainable Development / Fair Trade
Researcher / Trainer / Consultant



Thursday, October 20, 2011

A Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade: Human Rights Framework



Before we can talk about integrating a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade, we need to be familiar with Human Rights. To begin:

"Human rights are rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, sex, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, language, or any other status. We are all equally entitled to our human rights without discrimination. These rights are all interrelated, interdependent and indivisible" 
- UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights

Here is my challenge to you: Can you list your basic human rights? We assume we know  our rights, but how many can you list in the next ten minutes? Honestly, one reason that rights are violated every day is because too few have actually taken a moment to read this landmark document. As Dr. Mike Thair commented on the last post, "if you stick you head up and shout too loudly against a lot of these entrenched practices, you will soon be dealt with and knocked back into line... NGOs and the well meaning importers may have a lot of warm fuzzies running training programs, but does anything actually change for producers/artisans?"

So my challenge is simple: List your as many of your rights as you can, then grade yourself. To help, my partner Chou has used her creative talents to provide a copy of the UDHR here and I encourage you to post it in your workplace, in the community center, or in a public space! For those of you who are trading with producers whose first language is not English, the United Nations has translated this document into 131 languages: http://www.ohchr.org/EN/UDHR/Pages/SearchByLang.aspx.  It would be great if you could provide your trade partners with a copy!

Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Note: The posters in this document can be found on: http://www.reallygoodfriend.com/index.php?category=18

For many Fair Traders, whether they are a producer, an advocate, a member of an organization supporting Fair Trade producers, or a sales person in a small Fair Trade retail shop, being familiar with these internationally recognized rights provides you with the very foundation of Fair Trade. Personally, I would like to see the UN Human Rights conventions fully integrated into the Fair Trade Principles. At this time, only one UN Human Rights Convention is mentioned: the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). In fact, it is mentioned in the first sentence of Principle 5: Ensuring No Child Labour or Forced Labour

"The organization adheres to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, and national / local law on the employment of children."


Again, how many Fair Traders have actually read the CRC? More importantly, how many of your children have read this UN Declaration? Teaching children about their rights is important if we want children to grow up to be respectful of the rights of others. To facilitate, here is a downloadable poster of the convention in easy to understand English. Try this exercise with a child or a group of children and make it fun: List as many rights for children as you can and then compare your list to the convention! 
Convention on the Rights of the Child Easy Language Poster

The point of these exercises is to prove that rights are not some abstract idea in a distant UN document far from reality. Quite the contrary! These documents are tangible; these conventions form the foundation of the rights we enjoy on a day-to-day basis! The CRC has been translated into 58 languages and are available from UNICEF at their child-friendly page: http://www.unicef.org/magic/briefing/uncorc.html, so if you have trade partners whose first language is not English, download a copy and take the extra step to print it out on a poster size paper, laminate it, and mail it to them! What a terrific way to let them know you support and care for their children! 

What about Cultural Rights and Fair Trade? 
The Global Fair Trade movement respects and celebrates cultural diversity! As a matter of fact, it should be noted in the latest revision of the Fair Trade Principles (for a pdf copy go to: "Our Values, Our Shared Principles") the WFTO added to Principle 3: Trading Practices

"Fair Trade recognizes, promotes and protects the cultural identity and traditional skills of small producers as reflected in their craft designs, food products and other related services."

Not surprisingly, the foundation of this statement can be found in another UN Convention protecting social and cultural rights. In addition to the UDHR, the United Nations has established nine core international human rights treaties, eight of which are directly related to Fair Trade: 

 

What about Labour Rights? 
When it comes to labour rights, there is the International Labour Organization (ILO) which is "the only tripartite U.N. agency with government, employer, and worker representatives. This tripartite structure makes the ILO a unique forum in which the governments and the social partners of the economy of its 183 Member States can freely and openly debate and elaborate labour standards and policies." (http://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/who-we-are/lang--en/index.htm)

Created on the heels of World War I, it was founded on the belief that "universal and lasting peace can be accomplished only if it is based on social justice... The driving forces for ILO's creation arose from security, humanitarian, political and economic considerations."  

The ILO has passed multiple Conventions and Recommendations which establish the international labour standards relevant to Fair Trade today. Conventions, are legally binding international treaties that may be ratified by member states. Recommendations serve as non-binding guidelines. In many cases, a convention lays down the basic principles to be implemented by ratifying countries, while a related recommendation supplements the convention by providing more detailed guidelines on how it could be applied. 


As it stands, one of the ten Fair Trade Principles mentions the ILO, Principle 8: Ensuring Good Working Conditions:

"The organization provides a safe and healthy working environment for employees and / or  members. It complies, at a minimum, with national and local laws and ILO conventions on health and safety."

However, ILO conventions can be applied to many of the Fair Trade Principles. By overlapping the UN Declarations with the ILO Conventions and Recommendations we have established the framework for a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade. 

It is time for the Global Fair Trade Movement to thoroughly integrate internationally established Human and Labour Rights into our shared principles; 

It is time to Integrate a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade!!!

Sadly, the most glaring absence of reference to a UN Human Rights document is in Principle 6: Commitment to Non-Discrimination, Gender Equity, and Freedom of Association. Nowhere in this principle is there a reference to the most obvious Human Rights document, the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), 1979. Not only that, CEDAW is the only UN Convention to define Discrimination:

"‘Discrimination against women’ shall mean any distinction, exclusion or restriction made on the basis of sex which has the effect or purpose of impairing or nullifying the recognition, enjoyment or exercise by women, irrespective of their marital status, on a basis of equality of men and women, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural, civil or any other field.” – United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, Article 1

There is so much to say about this UN Convention and how the system works, I am saving it for the next blog post! My point here is that by integrating human rights into our shared principles, we will strengthen our ability to tackle poverty through trade. As I mentioned before, a Rights-Based Approach recognizes poverty as injustice and includes marginalization, discrimination, and exploitation as the central causes of poverty. 

This brings us back to Dr. Mike Thair's point - that the powers that be, whether they are political, social, or corporate oppressors, will beat you down and put you in line if you don't comply with the status quo. If a picture speaks a thousand words, here is my articulated response: 

Mahatma Gandhi, 1869 - 1948
Dorothy Day, 1897 - 1980
Martin Luther King, Jr, 1929 - 1968
Dalai Lama, 1935 - present
All are Rights Activists of one form or another, and all have greatly impacted our lives today through their commitment to a cause they believe in! Even more so, they each made great impacts on history while adhering to the principle on Non-Violence.

My point here is that six of the ten principles are directly related to human and labour rights. In order for Fair Trade to be sustainable into the future, do as Mother Jones succinctly stated: "Sit down and read. Educate yourself for the coming conflicts." To this end, I have created a framework to reference for Fair Trade activists, advocates, producers, researchers and supporters to integrate a Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade:
It is not necessary to memorize all these conventions, that is not the point; just become familiar with your rights in order that you can make change happen! Make it a fun activity, you may surprise yourself with what you already know or don't know about your rights in the UDHR and the CRC.

The first step in utilizing a Rights-Based Approach is knowing your rights.


Mitch Teberg, MA 
International Consultant
Sustainable Development / Fair Trade
Researcher / Trainer / Consultant   

For those who prefer reading black on white, here is the downloadable version of this post on pdf: 
A Rights-Based Approach to Fair Trade - Human Rights Framework

Thursday, June 30, 2011

"Our Values, Our Fair Trade Principles"

Ethical principles form the foundation of the Fair Trade, and when discussing these principles in practice we are really talking about the way business should be conducted around the world on a day-to-day basis, placing people and planet above profit and private gains. The principles are not a political ideology, but sensible, humane and logical aspirations for living on a shared planet.

In the last series, "From Principles to Practices", I focused on the importance of breaking down principles to an everyday occurrence. Coincidentally on June 20th, I received a weekly newsletter from Carola Reintjes, Chief Executive of the World Fair Trade Organization. In this newsletter she presented a terrific idea for promoting Fair Trade principles. With the permission of WFTO, I have reprinted that newsletter here:


Dear members, dear FAIR traders,
 
Shalom, Jambo, Dobar dan, Bula Wantok, Buenos días, Good day, Ciao, Bom dia, Nihao, Asalamou Aleikoum, Bonjour, Mabuhay, Konnichi wa, Namaste!
 
Today I would like to share with you a very simple proposal. I strongly believe in the simple and small things in life. Simple things and small gestures can have high impact, and can potentially change lives.
 
If a journalist asked you what it is that makes you different from other business, some of you might tell a long story, others might just say “We are fair traders”. But when this journalist keeps on insisting (surely a habit which characterizes all journalists around the globe), and asks what makes a Fair Trade Organization different from conventional companies, our answers will be very similar. We might not use the same words, we might express in multiple forms, but we will try to tell the journalist that our business is based on values. Some of us might mention our Fair Trade principles. The journalist will feel our pride when we explain to him/her our value-based approach to production and trade.
 
At the Mombasa AGM we approved our new WFTO Fair Trade System for membership, monitoring and certification which has at its core our 10 principles. We slightly changed the wording of our principles and incorporated the cultural identity into one of our principles. 
 
We would like to challenge you around our 10 principles. Can you imagine yourself, your colleagues, all employees, workers and producers knowing our principles? Just imagine! It would be very powerful.
 
Just imagine a visitor coming to see you, a buyer, a consultant, or an auditor. Imagine whomever he/she asks about your values, about the principles, and about how you incorporate these principles into your daily work, there will not be 50 different answers but only one common answer: a clear reference to our principles, and a clear explanation on how you work with these principles, how your organizations embeds them into your daily work.

 
Now my simple proposal:  
  •  Print our Fair Trade principles; 
  •  Make sure you only use the recent version approved at the Mombasa AGM; 
  •  (Download) the document in English (see below) and Spanish (see at bottom);
  •  Eliminate all previous versions from your files, only use this last version; 
  •  Distribute copies to your colleagues, employees, workers and producers; 
  •  Hang them on your wall at your work-place (desk, table, wall, …); 
  •  Assure everybody does the same; 
  •  Try to organize a short session every week, or ask for it to be organized; 
  •  During the session discuss collectively one of the principles (one every week); 
  •  In ten weeks your staff, workers and producers will have gone through a wonderful training on the 10 principles; 
  • Tell us about your sessions, tell us about your good experience,  but as well about the problems you come across when implementing the principles; 
  • Take photos during the sessions, film your sessions; 
  • Share your experience, photos, film, drawings, with us; 
  • We would like to share your good experience with other members, we will tell your story to motivate others.
This simple proposal is meant for all of us, producer organizations and marketing organizations, manufacturers and traders, exporters and importers, wholesalers and retailers. Don’t just assume that in your organization people are well trained on our principles, just because your organization has been in Fair Trade business for 20 or 30 years.
 
You might need to translate the principles into your local language/s.
You might need to convert them into graphics, drawings.
We surely cannot make the mistake to be exclusive around our values.  

All of our employees, workers and producers have a right to clearly understand what they are working for. Many hours of their live will be dedicated to Fair Trade, so we better make sure we reach out to all the people we are responsible for.
 
Our Fair Trade principles are our family silver. They make us unique in a highly competitive and exploitative world out there. Let us make sure we dedicate the attention our values deserve, and let us make sure each of the persons we are responsible for in our organization clearly understands and implements each of the principles.
 
We wish you a GOOD week, and an interesting first session,
 
On behalf of the Secretariat,
 
Carola           
WFTO © 2011
WFTO 10 Fair Trade Principles June2011-2

I like this idea because Carola's proposal is practical. It requires no costly effort and is essential to the sustainability of the Fair Trade Movement. More importantly, this activity needs to be done by organizations throughout the supply chain! There are many creative ways to make this a fun interactive and memorable activity. The best way to transfer ownership of these principles is through providing opportunities for staff and workers to teach others!  

The Principles of Fair Trade in Bahasa Indonesia,
at the workshop of a Mitra Bali silversmith

Most producer groups Chou and I met with on this journey had some degree of knowledge of the Fair Trade principles. Admittedly, there was room for improvement for some and an activity such as Carola suggests will definitely improve the situation. When principles are not shared with producers and key people within a Fair Trade Organization it can have disastrous results. In Cambodia, we witnessed how Fair Trade can fail those it is intended to benefit when the principles of Fair Trade were not integrated into the day-to-day operations and were not passed on to empower the craftswomen and men. Admittedly, it was the most challenging post to write because it was contrary to the results I had hoped to publish. 

In that blog post I
asked myself, "What do I do when I go to listen to the voices of Fair Trade, but the voices are absent? By absent, it is not that they are missing as in people do not want to share their views on what Fair Trade means to them... I found myself asking, what happens when, for no fault of their own, the very people who you go to listen to, don’t have an answer because they don’t know what you are asking?"  For insight to the personal and organizational effects of disregarding the principles, you can read the blog post:


However, the practice of our shared principles is not for producers alone! I can name at least one American certified Fair Trade importer who could really use Carola's activity (Read: Coffee Part II - "It's not my Problem"), and from what I have heard, it sounds like the problem is more wide spread than we would like to admit. 

Since starting this blog, I occasionally receive emails from people who plan to take similar journeys related to Fair Trade. Sometimes they are socially conscious backpackers, other times they may have something they wish to contribute to the Fair Trade movement and feel that a journey to meet producers is a good approach. Recently, I received an email from a Fair Trade / Environmental Activist in Spain. He shared his plan to conduct a journey of his own to follow-up on Fair Trade. However, as an advocate he expressed a sincere concern regarding the Fair Trade Movement in Spain that should be ringing alarm bells for all of us. With his permission, I reprint part of his email here: 

Hi Mitch,
I've just landed to your blog and I must sincerely congratulate for all your work and investigation in favor of fair trade. I work as environmentalist for Friends of the Earth - Spain, at the same time I'm involved in various non-prof fair trade, social and wildlife groups that keep myself happily busy and always on guard to fight for human and nature rights!!!

After many years involved in fair trade, social issues and environmental protection, I've decided to take a some time off to travel Asia and South America with the aim to visit communities and see if fair trade is really working as a catalyst for social and economic change and to value if we are all working towards building a sustainable future for both humans and nature.

I must say that there is a lack of transparency in FT issues in Spain, all shops buy direct from importers but there is a few information from importers on the real impact on communities: working conditions, families, health, education, rights,...everyone seems to be pretty happy just buying FT goods and no-one ask any further questions. To this point there are quite a few voices raising to demand more information and a real reports and analysis on FT impact on communities....but no-one seems to hear our demands.

In order to solve this lack of transparency and impact issue I've decided to travel to Asia and Latin-América to see things for myself. This journey will keep me on the move for at least two years. If everything works OK I hope to spend a year in Asia and the rest in Latin-América...

Warmest regards from Spain and all the best with your project, you are carrying out a fantastic work !!! 

I am encouraged by his personal commitment to follow-up on the impacts of Fair Trade. However, he also brings up a serious issue that directly relates to the importance of knowing the Fair Trade Principles regardless of where you find yourself in the supply chain. As an importer, retailer, consumer or advocate, how can we promote Fair Trade if we don't share the direct impacts of Fair Trade principles in a community?


One of the main motivating factors for Chou and I to embark on this journey was to learn about and present the impact of Fair Trade on producers. I have been in many Fair Trade shops and I am often disappointed that the only information about the producers is on a small sales tag. Surely Fair Trade retailers can provide more information than that! 

There are many ways to bridge the existing gap between producers and consumers. Here are a few examples that I have seen:
  • Provide handouts or brochures that offer links to producer websites.
  • Feature a simple one-page summary of a producer group each month with a couple photos.
  • Offer opportunities to travel to meet producer groups in near-by locations, or for the adventurous offer Fair Trade travel packages to foreign countries - I recently reviewed a brochure for Fair Trade tourism in Cebu, Philippines! Use the trip to take photos and get their stories to share in the store when you return!
  • Bring Fair Trade producers to connect directly with customers for a special occasion or fundraising event.
Information about the producers themselves, their community, the social issues they are addressing, and the impact of Fair Trade can be used as a selling point to connect consumers to producers; a value-added measure big box-store retailers can not offer. Unlike conventional trade, Fair Trade is intended to bridge the distance between producers and consumers; this is exactly the reason importers, retailers, their staff and Fair Trade volunteers could all benefit from Carola's suggestion. 

If the principles are understood throughout the supply chain, the information regarding the impact of Fair Trade is more readily shared! In many cases Fair Trade producers have websites and it is possible to see the impacts of Fair Trade through the information they provide. In other cases producers may not have access to the internet. In either case, the onus of responsibility for providing such information is on the importers and retailers alike. 

As Carola wrote, "We surely cannot make the mistake to be exclusive around our values." Find out how those principles are making a difference and share your findings!


Thank you for following our blog. Chou and I welcome your comments, ideas and suggestions as we delve into the multitude of issues surrounding Fair Trade. 

To be charitable is a virtue; 
     to be empowered is a human right. 

Fair Trade empowers the disadvantaged, integrates the marginalized, and supports the impoverished with viable livelihoods. Click here to donate to the Fair Trade.

Mitch Teberg, MA

Los Diez Principios Comercio Justo June2011

Friday, May 6, 2011

Celebrating the Malaysian Fair Trade Initiative



Work like you don't need the money.
Love like you've never been hurt.
Dance like nobody's watching.
- Satchel Paige


Unobserved and unimpeded, 
    I danced round and round in celebration... 

This exciting Journey  
    has far exceeded my wildest expectations. 

For me, the experience in Malaysia has proven to be a pinnacle of achievement; the application of lessons learned over the past five months culminated in the launch of a national Fair Trade Movement. A day I will cherish for a lifetime! The idea to create an awareness raising movement in Malaysia came through discussions with  Dr. Mike Thair and his wife, Linh of Indochine Natural Handmade Soap. They had been following my blog and presenting me with thought provoking commentary along the way. This turned into a discourse on how to create a national Fair Trade Movement that could be applied in the Malaysian social and political context. 


So, from the organic coffee farmer cooperatives of Aceh, my Journey brought me to Penang, Malaysia where I met Dr. Mike Thair and his wife, Linh. I also met his staff and his talented producers. It was a great opportunity to see how a soap-making business took Fair Trade to heart in their practices. I was most interested in his efforts to provide an income-generating opportunity for mentally disadvantaged men and women through soap-making with used cooking oil collected locally. It sells very well in Japan! 

Meeting with local consumer awareness organizations in Penang proved a bit difficult due to timing, however we did utilize the time to spearhead the efforts in Kuala Lumpur. We set the date for the first meeting to be Saturday, April 30th. That gave me two weeks in KL to do the groundwork.

Looking for a Few Good Catalysts!

From the moment I arrived it was a busy schedule. I met with interested individuals, academics, Non-Government Organizations, retail businesses and marginalized producer groups all of whom had some degree of knowledge on Fair Trade and were very interested in introducing this concept to Malaysian consumers. At every opportunity I discussed the possibilities of creating a Fair Trade Initiative and the importance of getting a core group of people involved that would take action. 


Mike Thair introduced me to Callie Tal, the CEO of JustLife, an organic shop, food store and retailer with six locations in KL. This successful business venture also serves as a much needed awareness raising platform on the importance of organically grown produce. Callie and her husband Darren have an interest in Fair Trade since they utilize an ethical business model in their transactions with the intention of making organic farming sustainable in Malaysia where there is a high dependence on chemical farming due to government policy of subsidizing the use of cancer causing chemical fertilizers, pesticides, insecticides, fungicides, herbicides and a wide array of death dealing chemicals used so carelessly in our foods (for more information check out the Pesticide Action Network - UK or the Pesticide Action Network - North America).

From the moment we met we had a terrific discussion on their source of organic produce which was coming from local farmers and also from more distant locations like the US and Australia. They have a great initiative, but I could see that the carbon footprint from the more distant sources has been worrisome to these conscientious retailers. Their Basic Question has been, How to provide organic produce without the CO2 from transporting long distances, yet have enough of a shelf life left to be consumable? A genuine dilemma for the socially and environmentally aware...


During my stay in Takengon, Aceh, I had the opportunity to meet directly with Johannes Egger, the FLO-Cert auditor. We discussed his audits of cooperatives in the region, and one recommendation he frequently makes is the need for farmers to diversify produce in addition to coffee. He pointed out there is an effort to grow avocado and I did see this. However, in his audits he continues to stress the need to introduce other varieties of produce to maintain a balance in soil nutrients and depend less heavily on coffee for family incomes. 

Consider with me,  just for a moment, 
     a Vision for the Future of Fair Trade...

Imagine, Fair Trade Localized in the South
     Ending a Dependance on Trade to the North
     
Envision Fair Trade Directly Contributing to Local, 
     National and Regional Economies in the South

For Fair Trade to be Sustainable,
     This Vision Must be Realized

With an interest in helping the farmers of Aceh lessen their dependence on coffee exports to the North through particular unscrupulous FLO-Certified importers who have little regard for the Principles of Fair Trade (Read Coffee Part II - "It's not my Problem"), and to more fully utilize their organic certification status, I mentioned the potential that was just across the Strait of Malacca in the mountains of Aceh. By putting JustLife in contact with the Indonesian Fair Trade Producers Association and with the Fair Trade Exporter, Mr. Sadarsah in Medan, I could do my part to localize Fair Trade in the South and greatly reduce their carbon footprint. This Vision of Fair Trade Localized is attainable!  

                            

I also had an opportunity to meet Elodie Viosin of Tanma, an organization founded under Tenaganita to directly assist Burmese Refugees in Malaysia. By refusing to recognize their UNHCR refugee status, the Malaysian State adds to the anguish of Burmese Refugees by not permitting them legal migrant status and ignoring their rights under the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families. Marginalized, persecuted, scapegoated, subject to raiding parties, and often used as a disposable labor pool, refugees find themselves in a precarious and depressing situation where there is little if any hope for a better future. 

Rampant alcoholism and drug abuse are common methods of escape. Perpetual fear of being shaken down for what little cash they have by local police, and the constant threat of being detained and shipped off to detention centers is enough to wear down the nerves of any human being. Employment is tenuous at best, and with no job security Burmese men are frequently exploited and cheated out of wages. Worse yet is that they are living under the constant threat of having their children targeted by pimps, traffickers and pedophiles due to the lack of legal and police protection. Life quickly becomes one of self-imprisonment behind locked doors with few outside connections beyond those who can be trusted.  

Despite the odds, Tenaganita and Tanma have been amongst the very few active supporters of this marginalized community while the vast majority simply turn their head from the human plight before their eyes, in the news and in their communities and don't consider it their problem. A sad commentary for a nation which prides itself in it's national identity. 

I had the opportunity to meet with two groups, the Chin Women and Children's Center making hand woven textiles and Kaoprise Beauty producing high quality, all natural hand-made soaps. I purchased several! True to his form and committed to the practices of Fair Trade, Dr. Mike Thair has been assisting the soap-making venture providing technical assistance and business advice. 


The groundwork to generate interest in this Malaysian Initiative was greatly assisted by the efforts of like-minded souls who had established an informal network already. I had the great opportunity to meet with Sze Ning, co-founder of Elevyn, an online Fair Trade shop where Tanma products can be purchased directly! 

When visiting the Chin Women and Children's Center where they were making woven handbags and hand-knitted dolls, I saw a young girl with her mother. She must have been about six years old, and the doll her mother had just completed was actively being hugged and loved. If this were an example of child labor, I can think of no better way to value-add to a Fair Trade doll than having it pre-approved in the loving arms of a six year-old with the most beautiful smile that lights up an entire room. In the midst of darkness, Tanma truly gives a glimmer of hope. 

In addition to setting out to bring like-minded and enlightened souls together to start a Fair Trade initiative, this journey to Malaysia was also a reunion. In 2009, I resided in KL for six months and during that time made a few life-long friends who turned up in my list of people to connect with to start this initiative. 

Nooreen Preusser is an enlightened being, kindred spirit, close friend and Director of P.S. The Children, a child-centered Child Rights organization that had a tremendous impact on me when I participated in a Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Course in 2009. Whether or not child sexual abuse is acknowledged by a state or religious establishment as a social problem, it is a universal occurrence that permeates all nationalities regardless of ethnicity or religion. Ignoring it only sanctions the abuse and facilitates the abuser. The only way to prevent it is to raise awareness of this issue to protect our children. I believe Fair Trade is a necessary platform from which to combat child labor, prevent child sexual abuse, and promote children's rights to education, play, health and safety.

In the midst of motivating, mobilizing, planning and reuniting, I received a call from a reporter from The Star, Malaysia's leading English newspaper. Leong Siok Hui, a senior reporter asked a few direct questions that implied she was well versed in Fair Trade, and afterwards, asked if I had attended the University of Montana in the USA -  as it turns out, we were classmates in the same Japanese language class. Little did I expect this reunion! 

The Start of a National Fair Trade Initiative

The Founding Members of the Malaysian Fair Trade Initiative,
in all there were about twenty!
Following two weeks of introductory meetings, in-depth discussions, training opportunities, planning and unexpected reunions, my efforts to generate interest in creating the Initiative paid off on Saturday, April 30th! The purpose of this meeting was to bring together NGOs, producers, farmers, Fair Trade businesses, retailers and socially conscious individuals all with a common interest in generating a synergy that would launch a national Fair Trade movement!

To start the meeting, I read a letter from Chief Executive of the World Fair Trade Organization, Carola Reintjies, welcoming Malaysians to the global Fair Trade Movement. Soon Malaysia will join the ranks of Fair Trade Movements in over 70 countries! The support and encouragement I have received in this effort has been terrific.

Because those in attendance had an understanding of Fair Trade, we did not need to cover the basics, and instead we dove headlong into our purpose. After a round of self-introductions, I seperated them into small groups to work together in a warm-up task:
  1. Describe what is the Malaysian Fair Trade Initiative about 
  2. Identify a common aim - "What is our message?"
  3. Suggest possible names for this initiative 

Darren of JustLife explains the importance of raising awareness
of Fair Trade with consumers and at all levels of the supply chain

Each group diligently worked together then presented their results. A lively and in-depth discussion ensued and over the next few hours the open conversation covered multiple aspects of Fair Trade: 
  • Fair Trade as a social movement and ethical business model versus a charity
  • Empowerment as a human right
  • The Global Movement of Fair Trade
  • The difference between FLO-Cert and the World Fair Trade Organization, and the synergy of the global movement
  • Global and regional strategies of WFTO and WFTO-Asia
  • Concerns over the chasm between the NGO sector and the private sector, and how Fair Trade straddles the gap
  • Practical limitations faced by producers, and changing expectations of buyers
  • The need for efficiency to be economically viable as a successful business venture 
  • Experiences shared in working with marginalized communities
  • Obstacles faced by retailers in sourcing and supply 
  • Common business practices in Malaysia and how to apply Fair Trade as a practical business model while being competitively priced on the market
  • and so on...
Dr. Mike Thair openly shares his experience in applying Fair
Trade principles into business practices and how it can be
utilized in the Malaysian context. To his left, his wife Linh and
Fair Trade Executive Director at Indochine Natural, and to the left
of her is the Elodie Viosin of Tenaganita.
Through this open discourse, the founding members began to create a collective vision for the future of Fair Trade as it is to be applied in Malaysia. As the meeting came to a close the  atmosphere was abuzz with the positive energy generated. With synergy generated and so much yet to cover, we ended our first meeting with a commitment to continuing these efforts to bring positive change to Malaysia with a global impact. Unnoticed, I took a quiet moment to close my eyes and slowly inhale; it was a natural high to have been part of this amazing day.

We set a second meeting date for Wednesday, May 25th to keep the momentum going and give enough time for the issues covered and lessons learned settle in. If you are in Malaysia and are interested in becoming part of something that is far greater than the sum of its members and far reaching on a global scale, join this grass-roots initiative! Unfortunately my Journey must go on to Vietnam, however I am confident what was initiated on April 30th will have a lasting impact on a nation!

The Founding Members of the Malaysian Fair Trade Initiative also include: 


A non-profit Christian organization
committed to serving the poor and needy.
     
Promoting Change.
Inspiring People.
Engaging Businesses.
                         

Malaysia's 1st cross-disability national magazine
for persons with disabilities

If I can do it, others can too! 

     Looking for a Few Good Catalysts!

          ...The Search is GLOBAL!




On this World Fair Trade Day, Saturday, May 14th, I encourage readers of this blog to unite with other like-minded and enlightened souls to bring change to your community, particularly if you are not already involved in a Fair Trade Movement. If you are involved in World Fair Trade Day events, read Catalysts for Social Change and bring a printout of the Fair Trade Advocacy Matrix with you to discuss ways to expand Fair Trade in your neighborhood, your town, your city, your state and your country! Regardless of where you are, you can make a change! If you are inspired by this blog, I am looking for a Few Good Catalysts to join me in creating Fair Trade Movements on World Fair Trade Day!   

Since 2006, I have been an Individual Associate of the WFTO. Without the backing of WFTO, the Fair Trade movement would not be sustainable, and most likely you would not be reading this blog. Let me be clear, I receive no payment from the WFTO, nor am I a representative of the WFTO. However, as an Individual Associate, I support the WFTO and its activities. If you want to have an impact on future generations by making the world a better place, I encourage you to take action on World Fair Trade Day and to donate to the WFTO. 


Donate to the WFTO Today
     Empower the Disadvantaged and Marginalized 
          Make an Impact on Generations

As for myself, this has been a completely self-funded and self-motivated inquiry. There have been no strings attached to what I post and I am beholden to no one other than the producers of Fair Trade products by my own accord. My intention is to compile my journey and the findings of my inquiry into a publication to be sold at your local Fair Trade shop or local socially conscious retailer. Soon enough I will be looking for a few good publishers...


On a personal note, today as I post this entry to my blog, there has been another distinguished accomplishment: the number of hits surpassed 10,000 with 50 followers in just 6 months. To those of you reading this blog, thank you. I never count my own hits on this blog, so they are all generated through you reading and sharing the site. Again, thank you.  

At some point you may have noticed my blog is not flooded with adverts, I oppose the commercialization of public media. When you visit my blog there is a notable absence of flashing, spinning and bouncing adverts bombarding the reader. Why do I take such a stance? I recently went to an online dictionary and clicked on an answer to trick question - it went directly to a porn site. I will not allow advertisers to negate my integrity.

For the last several weeks I have been supported on this journey by my life partner, Chou who had to return to Vietnam after graciously accompanying me for several months from Hoi An, Vietnam and into Cambodia, from the North to the South of the Philippines, and into Indonesia. Without her, these blog posts would not have been possible. Currently I am in Hanoi, Vietnam while she is setting up our residence in Ho Chi Minh City (Saigon). 

In Hanoi, I am consulting for Helvetas to create Fair Trade training material and methodology for Fair Trade producers worldwide. Helvetas is one of the co-founders of Max Havelaar Switzerland and supported the establishment of the Fair Trade Labelling Organization (FLO) which is one of the major organizations promoting Fair Trade worldwide. 

Thank you for joining me and Chou on this journey. If you have any comments, suggestions or ideas, I welcome all and invite you to comment below or catch me on facebook. 

To become a Catalyst for Social Change, all you need to do is take the initiative to start a Fair Trade Initiative!!   

Mitch Teberg, MA